Equity Culture

Tel: +44 (0)7956 691 104

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Board Evaluations
  • Regulatory Compliance
  • Clients and Case-Studies
  • Noticeboard
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Can Executive Directors cancel their SAYE scheme?

27th July 2009 9 Comments

“Our advisors have stated that our executive directors should not be permitted to cancel their SAYE savings schemes if, for instance, they wish to participate in a new scheme which has a lower option price than an existing scheme. Has anyone else received this advice?

If a director has cancelled an SAYE savings scheme, has anyone released an RIS on the subject? Or would you wait to disclose in the Remuneration Report?”

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Only your comment and indication of company type will be published

Comments

  1. FTSE 100 said

    27th July 2009 at 12:01 am

    We took advice from our Broker who commented that he did not foresee a problem. We did, however, carefully word a standalone RIS to manage any possible negative market reaction (of which we did not receive any).

    To avoid any problems with the timing of the £250 limit check by our SAYE carrier the directors withdrew a few weeks before the date of grant. The Broker advised the withdrawal could fall within the remit of DTR3.1 and therefore we were safest to issue an RIS announcement as soon as the withdrawal (and therefore the lapse of options) was effective.

    • FTSE 250 said

      27th July 2009 at 12:01 am

      I doubt that you can stop people cancelling on an individual basis where the proposed lower option price for a new grant would prompt people to do so, whether directors or not. However, the cancellation accelerates the accounting charge in that it is taken in full in the year of cancellation rather than being spread over the 3 or 5 years of the savings period. There is also a further charge in respect of the new options. We received advice that it may be possible to offer people the opportunity to ‘roll over’ the savings from the old option grant into the new one, without the charge being incurred. However it became clear that this was still being debated among the top 4 accounting firms so is not yet ‘ a runner’.

      • FTSE SMALL CAP said

        27th July 2009 at 12:01 am

        In line with other respondents – we allow directors and PDMRs to cancel SAYE options and announce it as part of the grant announcement. Similar to others, this has not attracted any adverse comment.

        • FTSE 250 said

          27th July 2009 at 12:00 am

          Our experience is in line with other respondents- we allow directors and PDMRs to cancel and announce it as part of the grant announcement. This has not attracted any adverse comment.

          • FTSE 250 said

            27th July 2009 at 12:00 am

            Same position as previous commentators. Directors churned 2007 SAYE at 79p for 2008 SAYE at 49p, which was announced. 98% of other employees in the 2007 scheme did exactly the same. No adverse comment received.

            My only other comment would be to change your advisor …

            • FTSE SMALL CAP said

              27th July 2009 at 12:00 am

              Although directors should be treated as any other employee in respect of SAYE options (most rules allow for employees to cancel their option at any time without providing a reason), given that cancellation of options gives rise to a P&L charge (as does issuing new options), it could be construed that in doing so a director would not be acting in the best interests of shareholders by creating an additional charge where they are looking to gain personally form doing so (especially if they re-subscribe for options at a lower exercise price).

              • FTSE 100 said

                27th July 2009 at 12:00 am

                I believe there is a view that Executive Directors should be confident in the long-term growth of their Company and therefore should remain within existing SAYE contracts. However, given the changes in current share prices and the markets in general, we feel this view is difficult to justify.

                We have not sought advice on this subject but for the last couple of years have allowed our directors (and PDMRs) to cancel existing SAYE contracts and participate in new schemes with lower option prices. We have included the information on the cancellations in the new award/grant RNS announcements, as well as in the following Rem Report. No adverse feedback has been received.

                • FTSE 100 said

                  27th July 2009 at 12:00 am

                  Our experience has been exactly the same. The cancellation was treated as a dealing and announced. No adverse reaction was received. I think this is common practice at a time of falling share prices. The whole purpose is to incentivise employees (including management).

                  • FTSE 250 said

                    27th July 2009 at 12:00 am

                    We have never sought advice on this subject, but a number of our directors and PDMRs have cancelled their SAYE contracts and participated in the new scheme with a lower option price. Our standard clearance procedure was followed and RIS announcements were made on each occasion. No adverse feedback was received.

                    Sections

                    • Home
                    • About Us
                    • Board Evaluations
                    • Regulatory Compliance
                    • Clients and Case-Studies
                    • Noticeboard
                    • Blog
                    • Contact Us

                    Recent Notices

                    • Providing copies of the Register of Members to external parties

                      Providing copies of the Register of Members to external parties

                      1st December 2022
                    • Related Party Transactions

                      Related Party Transactions

                      21st September 2022
                    • Should NEDs be required to hold shares in the company?

                      Should NEDs be required to hold shares in the company?

                      16th August 2022
                    • Board Support Assistant

                      Board Support Assistant

                      11th July 2022
                    • Interim Company Secretary Role

                      Interim Company Secretary Role

                      5th July 2022

                    Contact EquityCulture

                    Address:

                    89 Kesteven Way,
                    Corby,
                    Northamptonshire
                    NN18 8GF

                    Registered in England and Wales No. 06008649.

                    • Blog
                    • UK Board Evaluations
                    • UK Corporate Governance

                    © 2023 EquityCulture | Site Designed & Built by Midland Tech